I'll assume you've heard Aqua's version of the song: it's fun and cute, while remaining subversive. But have you heard the cover by Electric Chairs? They released an EP in 2001 of different mixes of the song. I haven't seen that EP (there can't be many copies in existence), but I first heard this song on The Orb's excellent "Back to Mine" mix CD (check out the entire series).
The Electric Chairs version really brings out the disturbing, menacing, predatory element* that is present in the Aqua version, but a lot easier to miss. When Aqua sings "Come on, Barbie, let's go party", it sounds like a dismissive critique. When Electric Chairs sing "Come on, Barbie, let's go party", it's a threat. And when the beat comes in (~2:38), it is simultaneously super cheesy and awesome -- a plastic but fantastic copy of what a dance beat should sound like.
Electric Chairs - "Barbie Girl (TF Long Version)"
Aqua - "Barbie Girl"
* I was tempted to draw a parallel to Sonic Youth's cover of the The Carpenters' "Superstar", but SY's cover changes the meaning of the song, inverting victim to predator. I think the Electric Chairs cover just emphasizes the scathing commentary that was lurking under Aqua's Europop veneer.
Update: We saw "Barbie" at Terry's place last week -- it was a clever and enjoyable film.
ReplyDelete